Diamond mines in the Northwest Territories are not a girl鈥檚 best friend

Diamond mines in the Northwest Territories are not a girl鈥檚 best friend

While marketing has made diamond rings a symbol of heteronormative happy endings, women from the Northwest Territories tell a different story about their experiences with the diamond mines.

By Rebecca Hall, Assistant Professor, Global Development Studies

May 5, 2022

Share

 

Two cut diamonds displayed on grey sand.
Canada鈥檚 diamond industry lauds itself as an ethical alternative to diamonds from elsewhere, but these gems are mined on Dene land and, in restructuring the lands and livelihoods of northern communities, the diamond industry brings with it a new, and newly gendered, colonial violence. (Unsplash/Bas van den Eijkhof)

Almost three years ago, the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (MMIWG) released its and among its findings, the report identified resource extraction as a site of gender violence.

The Conversation logoThe relationship between extraction and gender violence has been observed in . And in Canada, this is shaped by extraction and and livelihoods.

What is it about extractive projects that creates the conditions for gender violence?

In , I analyze the gender impact of Canadian diamond mines. As a settler researcher who grew up in southern Canada, I partnered with the and spoke with Dene, M茅tis, Inuit and non-Indigenous northern women about their experiences with the mines.

In Canada, the first diamond mine opened in the Northwest Territories on Dene land in 1998. Since then, three other diamond mines have opened there, and Canada has become the in the world.

The Canadian diamond industry was established amid around conflict 鈥 or blood 鈥 diamonds. Canada鈥檚 diamond industry lauds itself as an to diamonds from elsewhere, but these gems are and, in restructuring the lands and livelihoods of northern communities, the diamond industry brings with it a new, and newly gendered, colonial violence.

A pillar of settler development

Resource extraction has long been a pillar of in northern Canada.

Regionally, diamond mines were established on the heels of the longstanding gold industry, and they have reproduced some dynamics of past settler extractive projects. But the diamond mines have also brought with them new characteristics with unique gender impacts.

Unlike mining towns that sprouted up throughout the north in the 20th century, diamond mines are organized through a fly-in/fly-out (FIFO) structure. This means that workers fly in for prolonged mining shifts, and fly out for their time off.

FIFO, or DIDO (drive-in/drive-out), has become the preferred in . By making long-distance commutes part of everyday operations, the FIFO/DIDO model is an intensified expression of the home/work divide, where .

For many women workers I spoke to, the separation of work from home meant that work in the diamond mines was not accessible. This was because workers live away from home for extended periods of time, and weren鈥檛 able to care for kin and community.

This 鈥渃aring divide鈥 exacerbates existing tendencies for hypermasculine , or what the MMIWG report calls 鈥.鈥

Women who had worked at the diamond mines shared stories of intense visibility. These experiences ranged from a general feeling of greater scrutiny from other workers, to overt sexual harassment. While the women I interviewed held a variety of positions at the camps, it was women who worked in housekeeping and positions at a lower pay scale with higher degrees of precarity who described the most explicit and pervasive experiences with gendered discrimination and violence.

Heavy care burdens

The FIFO structure has led to on people, usually women, at home. While mine workers and their families spoke about the financial benefits of mine employment, many female spouses likened the experience of having a spouse at camp to single parenting.

One Dene woman I interviewed said:

鈥淚 feel like I live in a community where families are fragmented on purpose. We choose to remove half of the caregivers half of the time. How can this not have a significant impact on raising a family or being in a marriage?鈥

These heavy care burdens are coupled with new financial inequality within households, with mine workers often bringing in significantly higher wages than other family members.

The women I spoke with shared concerns that inequalities in both and finances were shaping conditions for interpersonal violence, and making it more difficult for women to leave violent situations.

When women shared their stories of the diamond mines, they did not express the impact as an isolated or unique phenomenon. Instead, I heard stories that wove the experiences of the diamond mines into ongoing processes of settler colonialism, including the .

Diamonds carry with them of romance and commitment, symbolizing a love that is, as diamond company De Beers puts it, 鈥渇orever.鈥

However, while a century of marketing has made diamond rings a symbol of heteronormative happy endings, when I spoke with northern women about their experience with the diamond mines, I heard a different story.

As one research participant said, 鈥淒iamonds are said to be a girl鈥檚 best friend. I鈥檓 not sure which girls they are because it鈥檚 certainly not anyone in here.鈥The Conversation

_______________________________________________

, Assistant Professor, Global Development Studies, .

This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the .

The Conversation is seeking new academic contributors. Researchers wishing to write articles should contact Melinda Knox, Director, Thought Leadership and Strategic Initiatives, at knoxm@queensu.ca.
Arts and Science