Researcher finds Canadian policing costs too high
March 31, 2014
Share
By Rosie Hales, Communications Officer
According to a study by Queen鈥檚 researcher Christian Leuprecht, if the cost of policing in Canada is to become more sustainable there must be a discussion surrounding the extent of police service and how these are delivered.
A debate about the extent and delivery of police services must take place immediately, according to a study by Queen鈥檚 researcher Christina Leuprecht.
鈥淭he current business model for police services in this country is unsustainable, especially considering there is no evidence that greater expenditure has either made the country any safer or improved the quality of service,鈥 he says.
Dr. Leuprecht, a professor in the School of Policy Studies and Department of Political Studies at Queen鈥檚, says Canada spent $12 billion, or nearly 1 per cent of gross domestic product, on policing in 2012. He recommends prioritizing police responsibilities to reduce that expenditure.
鈥淭he scope of policing has expanded greatly in recent decades,鈥 says Dr. Leuprecht. 鈥淥rder is integral to freedom. But in a liberal democracy that is premised on limited state intervention, we should be debating 鈥榳hat kind鈥 of policing instead of 鈥榟ow much.鈥欌
The study features other ideas for containing the costs of police services for Canadians.
鈥淲e need to place a much higher emphasis on quality over quantity when it comes to policing,鈥 says Dr. Leuprecht. 鈥淎s well, we need to shift the emphasis of police work away from law enforcement and towards 鈥榩eace officer.鈥欌
Order is integral to freedom. But in a liberal democracy that is premised on limited state intervention, we should be debating 鈥榳hat kind鈥 of policing instead of 鈥榟ow much.鈥
In his study, Dr. Leuprecht makes a case for economies of scale and reducing overhead, for example through greater use of technology by police in Canada to cut costs. This includes sharing court records online instead of using paper and cutting down on administrative work by using electronic messaging techniques (such as email or text messaging) to send minor offence notices.
However, Dr. Leuprecht suggests that with up to 90 per cent of police budgets spent on salaries, core and discretionary policing activities will have to be triaged to become more efficient, effective, productive, affordable and sustainable.
鈥淚n 2012, Canada spent $12 billion, or nearly 1 per cent of gross domestic product, on policing alone,鈥 says Dr. Leuprecht. 鈥淭he current business model for police services in this country is unsustainable, especially considering there is no evidence that greater expenditure has either made the country any safer or improved the quality of service.鈥
The study, The Blue Line of the Bottom Line of Police Services in Canada? Arresting Runaway Growth in Costs, was released by the Macdonald-Laurier Institute and .